Skip to content
New PeakSolutions

Talent

What a good technical interview actually tests

New Peak Talent Practice6 min read
Colleagues in a working session around a laptop

Trivia questions and whiteboard puzzles screen out good engineers. Here is how our practitioners evaluate candidates instead.

Every candidate we present to a client has been through a technical conversation with a practitioner from our consulting teams. Over more than a decade we have learned that the most useful interviews look a lot like the job itself, and very little like an exam.

Judgment over recall

Anyone can look up syntax. What separates strong engineers is how they reason about trade-offs: when to add a cache, when a simple script beats a framework, how to roll back a bad deployment. We ask candidates to walk through decisions they have made and what they would do differently.

Realistic problems

  • Review a short pull request and explain what you would change
  • Debug a failing pipeline from its logs
  • Sketch how you would migrate a small service to the cloud
  • Explain a past incident and what the team learned

Communication is part of the skill

Consultants work with stakeholders who are not engineers. We pay attention to how clearly a candidate explains a technical idea, whether they ask clarifying questions and how they respond when they do not know an answer. Saying "I am not sure, here is how I would find out" is a strong signal, not a weak one.

We are not looking for people who know everything. We are looking for people who know what to do next.

Respect for the candidate's time

Strong candidates have options. Long take-home assignments and five-round processes drive them away. We keep our technical screen to about an hour, give feedback quickly and help clients design interview loops that are thorough without being exhausting.

The result is a shortlist our clients can trust, and a candidate experience that reflects well on everyone involved.

All insights

Written by the Talent Practice